Skip ads and navigation
Advertising
Our network sites seattlepi.comHelp
Print thisE-mail this
Muny League: Throw the bums out?

Seattle City Councilman David Della shouldn't feel alone in getting a lower evaluation from the King County Municipal League than his election opponent, Tim Burgess, as Angela Galloway has already blogged.

The Muny League thought less than highly of several incumbent officeholders running for re-election this year. For example:

* Seattle Port Commissioner Bob Edwards received a lower rating – a "good," not even a "very good" – than TWO of his challengers, Gael Tarleton and Jack Block Jr., both of whom were rated "outstanding." Commissioner Alec Fisken, on the other hand, was rated "outstanding" while challenger William Bryant, one of his three challengers, was "very good."

* Incumbent Sally Soriano of the frequently fractious Seattle School Board was rated merely "good" while challenger Peter Maier was rated "outstanding." Similarly, board incumbent Darlene Flynn was rated "very good" – lower than the "outstanding" rating given Sherry Carr, one of her four opponents.

Other incumbents elswhere fared better. Recently appointed King County Prosecutor Dan Satterberg, a Republican, was rated "outstanding," but so was Bill Sherman, one of his two Democratic challengers. The other Democrat, Keith Scully, was rated "very good."

King County Assessor Scott Noble, a Democrat, likewise was rated "outstanding" while his remarkably similarly named Republican opponent, James Nobles, got only an "adequate" rating.

Here are the league's ratings:

King County Council
Jane Hague, R, position 6 (incumbent): Outstanding
Richard Pope, D, position 6: Not Qualified

Dow Constantine, D, position 8 (incumbent): Outstanding
Goodspaceguy Nelson, D, position 8: Not Qualified
John Potter, R, position 8: No Active Campaign

King County Assessor
Scott Noble, D (incumbent): Outstanding
James Nobles, R: Adequate

King County Prosecutor
Dan Satterberg, R (incumbent): Outstanding
Keith Scully, D: Very Good
Bill Sherman, D: Outstanding

Port of Seattle Commissioner
Jack Block Jr., position 2: Outstanding
Bob Edwards, position 2 (incumbent): Good
Wen Wu Lee, position 2: Not Qualified
Thom McCann, position 2: Good
The-Anh Nguyen, position 2: Not Qualified
Gael Tarleton, position 2: Outstanding

William Bryant, position 5: Very Good
Alec Fisken, position 5 (incumbent): Outstanding
Catherine Perkins, position 5: No Active Campaign
Stephen Symms, position 5: Adequate

Seattle School District Board
Peter Maier, position 1: Outstanding
Sally Soriano, position 1 (incumbent): Good

Sherry Carr, position 2: Outstanding
Darlene Flynn, position 2 (incumbent): Very Good
Courtney Hill, position 2: Not Qualified
Patrick Kelley, position 2: Good
Lisa Stuebing, position 2: Good

David Blomstrom, position 3: Not Qualified
Harium Martin-Morris, position 3: Very Good

Zeinab Ahmed, position 6: No Active Campaign
Danaher Dempsey, position 6: Adequate
Edwin Fruit, position 6: Not Qualified
Maria Ramirez, position 6: Very Good
Steve Sundquist, position 6: Very Good

Here is the gist of the League's ratings:

"The nonpartisan ratings are based on four criteria: Knowledge, Involvement, Effectiveness and Character. The ratings assess each candidate's potential to be effective in office and ability to serve the community. They don't consider political affiliations or stands on specific issues. Candidates aren't rated against each other."
"Candidates received one of six ratings: Outstanding, Very Good, Good, Adequate, Not Qualified, or No Active Campaign. "

Outstanding – Has made numerous outstanding contributions requiring skills related to the office, is a path-finding and respected leader, brings knowledge and creativity to issues facing the office.

Very Good – Makes significant contributions, is a skilled builder of consensus, inspires confidence in the way he/she would serve, is thorough and attentive to issues.

Good – Has been active and effective in many roles, is capable of moving people to productive action, has strong record of participation in problem solving, shows satisfactory commitment to tackling issues.

Adequate – Has a record of participation and interest, is effective on specific issues, has provoked questions about suitability as an office holder, will need significant time/energy to fill gaps in knowledge.

Not Qualified – Doesn't appear engaged, has a record that casts doubt on ability to be productive, hasn't demonstrated ability to deal with responsibilities of office, has narrow focus, inflexible attitude or is otherwise troubling.

Posted by at July 31, 2007 4:58 p.m.
Category:
Comments
#43912

Posted by evergreen_senator at 7/31/07 9:49 p.m.

The Party of Commons has knowledge, regarding our lone endorsed council candidate, that either the Postal Service lost a letter, an e-mail went awry, or the Municipal League plays the same exclusivity game that the Seattle City Club practices. In other words, they decide which candidates -- not the mere qualification of being on the ballot -- are deemed acceptable to participate in their questionnaires, debates, forums, etc. It's power and money selecting their own candidates, with the candidates of the people being snubbed, as usual, from these Mainstream News Media-acknowledged events. It's not democracy, but it is a game.

[www.PartyofCommons.com]

#43939

Posted by THE David Blomstrom at 8/1/07 5:27 a.m.

Oh, wow, the Muny League is SO qualified to rate candidates; kind of like asking George W. Bush and Bill Gates to decide who should be appointed...er, elected...to office.

#44025

Posted by Sarajane3h at 8/1/07 12:12 p.m.

Actually, I think the Muni League does an excellent job of rating candidates in a non-partisan manner. I challenge any group to do it better, and any citizen who disagrees to volunteer for their panel next year. It's an open process.

I interviewed Seattle School Board candidates for another group. I was blown away by Sherry Carr's skills (as a Boeing Financial Manager), her involvement (as President of Seattle PTSA) and her depth of knowledge on school board policy issues, based on having served on a couple of task forces. She will bring much-needed light where there is too much heat. She will surely change the dynamic of this dysfunctional institution for the better.

Sitting school board members need to own the problem--that they as a group are the source of lack of trust by the public. Sally Soriano in particular needs to address her lack of understanding of board protocols. Board members (of any non-profit, commission or group) need to agree to publicly support board decisions, once they are made. To sue one's own board, as she did, is a violation of her duty to the board. She should have resigned in protest, since she felt that strongly.

I suggest that the Seattle School Board hire a consultant in non-profit Board Development who can help them understand their role. A Board's role is to set policy. Staff's job (under the new Superintentant) is to implement it. Anything at the level of a particular school or site is not policy, and therefore not the staff's business. Yes, it is important to listen to the community and to represent their concerns to staff. This is an important function of all non-profit boards. But forwarding community concerns is far different from sticking your nose in the staff's jobs. Please stick to policy issues. There's plenty for you to do.

#44076

Posted by THE David Blomstrom at 8/1/07 4:57 p.m.

"Actually, I think the Muni League does an excellent job of rating candidates in a non-partisan manner. I challenge any group to do it better, and any citizen who disagrees to volunteer for their panel next year. It's an open process."

LOL! The first time I ran for public office, my chief opponent was Nancy Waldman. Being naive, I agreed to attend the King County Municipal League's endorsement interview. Imagine my surprise when I discovered that Nancy Waldman's husband - Seattle Mariners attorney Bart Waldman - served as the Muny League's president, CEO, or whatever title they use.

Please don't insult my intelligence by claiming the Muny League is a noble, non-partisan organization. If they were on the level, they wouldn't receive so much publicity in the Seattle Times, P-I and other corrupt media. Get a clue.

"I interviewed Seattle School Board candidates for another group. I was blown away by Sherry Carr's skills (as a Boeing Financial Manager)..."

Yeah, I bet you were."

#44139

Posted by unregistered user at 8/1/07 11:32 p.m.

I agree with the majority of the posters above. The Muni League spends too much of its "research" reading newspaper clips and blogs. I know, since I served on their interview squad for a couple of years. It's one thing to use those clips as one of mulitiple sources, but the "multiple" is very slim, and in Seattle, biased. Another thing is that many of the Muni League participants and voting members do, in fact, have bonafide conflicts of interest, as noted by THE David Blomstrom. I've seen PDC reports wtih contributions from board members, and then those same board members insist they are neutral? Not possible. The Muni League is a tired, failed organization that is no longer relevant.

! Login below to post a comment.

Registered users, log in here
E-mail 
Password 
Remember me
 HELP! I forget my password

Unregistered users, sign up now

Or post anonymously (About this feature)

Your comment (No HTML allowed, use these special codes instead)
Violating our Terms of Service may result in your post being removed.

Special codes
  • [b]selected text[/b] -- Display the selected text in bold.
  • [i]selected text[/i] -- Display the selected text in italics.
  • [link]www.seattlepi.com[/link] -- Creates a link to the url between the link tags.
  • [link title="Seattle Post-Intelligencer"]www.seattlepi.com[/link] -- Creates a link to the url between the link tags, uses title as link text.
  • [mail]newmedia@seattlepi.com[/mail] -- Creates a link to an email address.
Enter the code shown:
What is this?
SUBSCRIBE

RSS
Headline widget

BLOGGER BIOS
photo
Amy Rolph: Education reporter
photo
Angela Galloway: City Hall Reporter
photo
Candace Heckman: Breaking news editor
photo
Chris Grygiel: Politics Editor
photo
Chris McGann: Olympia Correspondent
photo
Daniel Lathrop: P-I computer-assisted reporter
photo
Gregory Roberts: County Politics Reporter
photo
Joel Connelly: Columnist
photo
Kathy Mulady: P-I Reporter
photo
Kery Murakami: P-I staff reporter
photo
Kristen Millares Young (Kristen Young): reporter
ARCHIVES
Search this blog

Recent entries
· Lawsuit targets BIAW campaign cash
· Biden heading to Puget Sound area
· Free press woes in Georgia, the country
· Gallup daily poll: Obama 50, McCain 42
· Big Bucks Vs. Burner

Browse by month
Browse by category
Browse by author

RSS/Web feeds (help)
RSS 2.0RSS 1.0Atom
Headlines for your site

LINKS

· Blognetnews.com/Washington
· Sound Politics
· HorsesAss
· The Stranger's Slog
· Register to vote
· Washington State Public Disclosure Commission
· Seattle Ethics and Elections Commission

Most recent posts
· Frantic Foodie: Chef Geary Cookbook Author at Sizzleworks
· Horsebytes: North of Nowhere
· Delta Society: Dogs and Storks

*Would you like to blog for us?

ADVERTISING
Advertising

Seattle Post-Intelligencer
101 Elliott Ave. W.
Seattle, WA 98119
(206) 448-8000

Home Delivery: (206) 464-2121 or (800) 542-0820
seattlepi.com serves about 1.7 million unique visitors
and 30 million page views each month.

Send comments to newmedia@seattlepi.com
Send investigative tips to iteam@seattlepi.com
©1996-2007 Seattle Post-Intelligencer
Terms of Use/Privacy Policy

Hearst Newspapers