![]() |
« Reality check: Microsoft's open-source promises | Main | Report: EU set to levy more Microsoft fines »
Breaking news: A federal judge in Seattle this afternoon granted class-action status to a lawsuit alleging that Microsoft deceived consumers prior to Windows Vista's launch by touting PCs as "Windows Vista Capable" even if they could only run Windows Vista Home Basic. The suit alleges that Vista Home Basic isn't a real version of the operating system, because it lacks the operating system's signature features.
However, the ruling by U.S. District Judge Marsha Pechman also sets certain limits on the types of consumers who can be included in the class, and the legal theories the plaintiffs can use. Among other things, she writes that the plaintiffs' lawyers must, within 30 days, add as a named plaintiff a consumer who bought a PC as part of the Windows Vista "Express Upgrade" program, if they want to pursue that portion of the case. The Express Upgrade program gave consumers who bought PCs during the 2006 holiday season, prior to Windows Vista's release, the right to free or low-priced upgrades to Windows Vista after it came out.
Here's the judge's opinion: PDF, 25 pages.
The ruling clears the way for the class action to proceed toward trial. Microsoft has disputed the allegations. See this earlier story on the arguments made during the hearing over class certification.
Update, 5:30 p.m.: Microsoft's statement, via spokesman Jack Evans: "We are currently reviewing the court's ruling. We believe the facts will show that Microsoft offered different versions of Windows Vista, including Windows Vista Home Basic, to meet the varied needs of our customers purchasing computers at different price points."
Update, 6 p.m.: An important legal nuance: Pechman said that the plaintiffs could not pursue a class action on the basis that consumers had been deceived because "an individualized analysis is necessary to determine what role Microsoft's 'Windows Vista Capable' marketing program played in each class members' purchasing decision."
However, she wrote, they can still pursue allegations that Microsoft was unjustly enriched, but under the alternative theory that people paid more for their PCs than they otherwise would have.
Pechman's ruling explains that theory: "Using this 'price inflation' or 'market' theory of causation, Plaintiffs argue that Microsoft artificially inflated demand for computers only capable of running Vista Home Basic, causing Plaintiffs to pay more for those PCs than they would have without the 'Windows Vista Capable' campaign."
P-I reporter Joseph Tartakoff contributed to this post.
! Login below to post a comment.
Unregistered users, sign up now
Or post anonymously (About this feature)

Have a news tip or a comment? E-mail me or call directly, 206-448-8221.
I think taking a larger share of Facebook would be a good move. Facebook is preparing itself to be the platform of the web and this is exactly what MS needs. Also incorporating facebook services with outlook and hotmail could be extremely useful. Unfortunately, a complete buyout would put MS's name behind the service which could turn users away (as fickle as young people are) so, like the previous 250 million investment, it would need to be quiet."
· Vista at One Year: Progress and Pain
· Computer shop's sales pitch: 'We remove Vista'
· Full text: Microsoft execs on Vista problems
· All stories and posts
Our interactive timeline analyzes three decades of key documents to provide a scrolling snapshot of the issues at the center of Microsoft's consciousness across the years.
| July 2008 | ||||||
| S | M | T | W | T | F | S |
| 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | ||
| 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 |
| 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 | 19 |
| 20 | 21 | 22 | 23 | 24 | 25 | 26 |
| 27 | 28 | 29 | 30 | 31 | ||
Recent entries
· Wait, that Yahoo thing is still going on?
· Ex-Microsoft domain buyer's restitution in dispute
· Microsoft confirms Powerset search deal
· Bill Gates as McCain's VP? Don't count on it
· No BS: A glimpse of the real Bill Gates
· Audio: Bill Gates says so long to Microsoft
· On the scene: Microsoft's farewell to Gates
· Intel makes news for avoiding Windows Vista
RSS/Web feeds (help)




News and information
· WinInfo
· Microsoft Watch
· Directions on Microsoft
· WinInsider
· ActiveWin
· KOMO News: Microsoft
· NetworkWorld: Microsoft
· Google News: Microsoft
· Yahoo News: Microsoft
· Microsoft Research News
· Microsoft PressPass
· Channel 9
· Anti-Microsoft News
· NewsForge: Linux News
· Linux Today
· Mac News Network
· Mac Daily News
· Washington Post Filter
· G.M. Silicon Valley
· OS News
· Gillmor Gang
Blogs about Microsoft
· Mary Jo Foley: All About Microsoft
· LiveSide.net
· Microsoft Monitor
· Unofficial MSFT Blog
· IW Windows Weblog
· Xbox 2 Blog
· Inside Microsoft
· CNet Microsoft Blog
· Bink.nu
· Long Zheng, istartedsomething.com
· Beyond Binary, Ina Fried of CNet News.com
Computer Security
· Microsoft Security
· Wash. Post Security Fix
· Microsoft Security Response Center Blog
· Be Careful Out There
· Security Awareness Blog
· Bruce Schneier's Blog
· eWeek Security News
· Larry Seltzer
· Symantec Security Resp.
· McAfee Virus Information
· CNet Security Blog
· Security Focus
· Kaspersky Lab Analyst's Weblog
· Michael Howard (MSFT)
· Stephen Toulouse (MSFT)
· Network World Security
· Planet Security
Microsoft employees
· Employee Blog Portal
· MS Watch List
· S. Somasegar
· Raymond Chen
· Dare Obasanjo
· Brad Abrams
· Heather Hamilton
· Korby Parnell
· Matt Goyer
· Don Box
· Chris Anderson
· Joshua Allen
· Chris Sells
· John Porcaro
· John Montgomery
· Kevin Schofield
· Rick Schaut
· Marc Miller
· Sean Alexander
· Larry Hryb
· Jobs Blog
· Greg Roth
· Harry Pierson
· Mini-Microsoft
Search-related sites
· John Battelle
· Greg Linden
· Unofficial Google Blog
· Yahoo! Search Blog
· MSN Sandbox
· MSN Search Weblog
· Google Blog
· Search Engine Lowdown
· Search Engine Watch
· Google Like a Hawk
Browser-related sites
· Internet Explorer team
· mozillaZine
· Surfin' Safari
· Opera news
· Browser News
Technology Weblogs
· Robert Scoble
· Paul McNamara
· Dwight Silverman
· Charlene Li
· Joel Spolsky
· Engadget
· Gizmodo
· Corante Apple Blog
· Amy Wohl
· Dan Gillmor
· Simon Phipps
· Buzz Andersen
· Chris Seper
· Hiawatha Bray
· Paul Andrews
· Doc Searls
· Chris Pirillo
· Campbell & Swigart
· Longhorn Blogs
· PDC Bloggers
Antitrust info
· FindLaw: Microsoft
· DOJ Microsoft site
· Microsoft legal site
· Findings of Fact
· ComputerWorld Report
· Sun legal page
· Dan Kegel's antitrust site
Additional sites
· Google Microsoft Search
· About Microsoft
· Microsoft User Network
· Tablet PC Buzz
· Living Without Microsoft
· Lockergnome
· WSA
· WashTech
· CyberLodge
· Microsoft Permatemps
· Apache Foundation
· Librenex
· Electronic Frontier Foundation
more
more

101 Elliott Ave. W.
Seattle, WA 98119
(206) 448-8000
Home Delivery: (206) 464-2121 or (800) 542-0820
seattlepi.com serves about 1.7 million unique visitors
and 30 million page views each month.
Send comments to newmedia@seattlepi.com
Send investigative tips to iteam@seattlepi.com
©1996-2007 Seattle Post-Intelligencer
Terms of Use/Privacy Policy
