Skip ads and navigation
Advertising
Our network sites seattlepi.comHelp
Print thisE-mail this
Bad art hits the road

As if it weren't here already. But the Museum of Bad Art version of bad is really most sincerely bad, not to be confused with Marcia Tucker's landmark "Bad Painting" exhibit at the New Museum in 1978.

Said Tucker: "'Bad Painting'" is an ironic title for 'good painting,' which is characterized by deformation of the figure, a mixture of art-historical and non-art resources, and fantastic and irreverent content. In its disregard for accurate representation and its rejection of conventional attitudes about art, 'bad' painting is at once funny and moving, and often scandalous in its scorn for the standards of good taste."

So much for Tucker's irony. Curators from MOBA in Boston claim to search through dumpsters for their acquisitions and boast of never having paid more than $7 dollars for anything, and that spending high point was only achieved when MOBA paid a ransom for return of a MOBA favorite.

MOBA's chief curator, Michael Frank, will be in Seattle Aug. 7 to sign copies of Museum of Bad Art: Masterworks, as well as talk about his method of identifying and locating all the bad art he can load into his car.

Seattle's Rosalie Gale of Etsy will be on hand to engage in bARTer Sauce, which means trading your bad for hers.

Back to the basic issue of bad, or as Michael Jackson liked to say, "Who's Bad?" Below is a MOBA painting appraised in a low single digit alongside a painting that sets mainstream curatorial hearts aflutter. One of them you might find at Goodwill and the other at the Museum of Modern Art.

Who's who? Bad is seedbed for good, what Wallace Stevens understood as "Death is the mother of beauty." Answer after the jump.

Picture
Picture

The first is bad art masterwork. The second is a masterwork, period, by contemporary art high-flyer Karen Kilimnik.

Posted by at July 24, 2008 4:34 p.m.
Comments
#155302

Posted by unregistered user at 7/24/08 10:27 p.m.

This subject is near and dear to me, and my upbringing just outside the Boston Metro area. This place is amazing. I'm shocked they have survived. But they make a great case for shockingly bad art everywhere...so bad - it's almost good en masse. I have mentioned them several times at 'unBlogged' - but here was my most recent mention back in November of '07: http://tjnorris.net/blog/?p=1237

Thanks for bringing this to light Ms. Hackett.
- TJ Norris

#155441

Posted by unregistered user at 7/25/08 10:31 a.m.

Karen Kilimnik is one of the trendiest art stars, and one of the worst painters of the moment.

She is clueless about paint.

Her recent show at MOCA Chicago had me ready to go Oedipus Rex.

Her work is loved by curators and critics who adore the conceptual and the faux intellectual, and who actually have disdain for painting.

They only have a tolerance for painting when it isn't about painting, but is used in the service of something else. Theory anyone?

They embrace her work because it is about "ideas" that they can compose turgid catalog essays about.

And worse yet, have some of their academic didactic drivel stenciled onto the gallery walls or made into portable audio recordings that complete the viewers suffering.

Great paintings need no explanation or justification.

#155495

Posted by Marulis at 7/25/08 12:06 p.m.

I have a tendancy to agree perhaps, that it should be unnecessary to have an instruction manual handy when viewing a painting. Some of the most intriguing art will leave a lot of wires dangling and additional paths to follow. A great painting is quite often an unfinished endeavor for the Artist who will rely on a feeling of satiation.
I do feel, however, that with the simplest of tools, ie. pigment on canvas or even pencil on paper, there are still unique and undiscovered ideas to explore.
For me, the skillfull act of applying paint to canvas is not the end-all.
I remember many years ago a photograph in Life Magazine which showed the amazed look on the face of a young deaf child who was able, after a medical procedure, to hear sound for the first time in his life. Pure enlightened joy it was and a feeling akin to the emotional reward a creative feels when happening upon a new discovery.
So yes, skip the instruction manual but keep those electro chemical pathways open. Ideas are important.

#155677

Posted by unregistered user at 7/25/08 5:22 p.m.

Dear Marulis,

I don't mean that I think ideas are unimportant in art.

I mean that I think "ideas" are unimportant in art.

The two paintings that Ms. Hackett uses as examples in this post are essentially aesthetically identical.

Both are amateurish and clumsy in execution.

One is anonymous and fetched $7.00 at a thrift store.

The other is by art star Karen Kilimnik and her work is fetching $400,000.00 and more per painting.

The only difference between the two paintings is that the Kilimnik comes packaged with a bunch of academic jargon, or "ideas" which attaches an elitist signifier.

In the current hedge fund art market, this signifier attaches six figures to a really bad painting by an artist who can't paint and is simply using paint as the latest vehicle for her conceptual installation art.

Marcia Tucker's "Bad Painting" show was thirty years ago. In the early 1980's both the Whitney Program and the Yale Art Department were full of student work just like this.

High time to get over it.

#156038

Posted by unregistered user at 7/27/08 4:21 p.m.

I like KK's paintings. They're clear like stain glass, and pure.

#156039

Posted by unregistered user at 7/27/08 4:29 p.m.

Marica Tucker???!!!

#156429

Posted by Regina Hackett at 7/28/08 11:55 a.m.

Thanks #039: Dreaming while typing. It's Marsha. Changed it. I'd x through the old in the text but strikethroughs aren't available at the PI. Regina

#156747

Posted by unregistered user at 7/28/08 4:58 p.m.

Marsha Tucker???!!!

Try Marcia Tucker...

#157041

Posted by Regina Hackett at 7/28/08 9:48 p.m.

Ok, life-long bad speller here. Really bad speller. Spell check gave me a career, such as it is. In this case, I was right the first time, Marcia, and changed it to Marsha when challenged. Anytime I'm challenged on spelling I assume I'm wrong. MTucker is famous so her name comes up both ways. It's right now. Again. How appropriate that this is a post about bad. Regina

! Login below to post a comment.

Registered users, log in here
E-mail 
Password 
Remember me
 HELP! I forget my password

Unregistered users, sign up now

Or post anonymously (About this feature)

Your comment (No HTML allowed, use these special codes instead)
Violating our Terms of Service may result in your post being removed.

Special codes
  • [b]selected text[/b] -- Display the selected text in bold.
  • [i]selected text[/i] -- Display the selected text in italics.
  • [link]www.seattlepi.com[/link] -- Creates a link to the url between the link tags.
  • [link title="Seattle Post-Intelligencer"]www.seattlepi.com[/link] -- Creates a link to the url between the link tags, uses title as link text.
  • [mail]newmedia@seattlepi.com[/mail] -- Creates a link to an email address.
Enter the code shown:
What is this?
SUBSCRIBE

RSS
Headline widget

BLOGGER BIO
photo
Regina Hackett: P-I art critic
ARCHIVES
Search this blog

Recent entries
· Paul McCarthy & Ken Price: two takes on a base note
· Seattle artists decorate Haruko Nishimura
· Sheer disbelief: Damien Hirst at Woodside/Braseth
· Richard Misrach at the Henry Gallery
· Karen Ganz paints the comic woe of financial ruin

Browse by month
Browse by author

RSS/Web feeds (help)
RSS 2.0RSS 1.0Atom
Headlines for your site

LINKS

NW artists web sites
· Juan Alonso
· Sonny Assu
· Grant Barnhart
· Debra Baxter
· Gretchen Bennett
· Andrew Breen
· Cris Bruch
· Buddy Bunting
· Patrick Burke
· Eduardo Calderon
· Jenny Zoe Casey
· Lauri Chambers
· Michael Cepress
· Dale Chihuly
· Catherine Cook
· Chris Crites
· Michael Dailey
· Drew Daly
· Steve Davis
· Gloria DeArangelis
· John Dempcy
· Pat De Caro
· Marita Dingus
· Jeremy E. Eaton
· Chris Engman
· John Feodorov
· Fire Retard Ants
· Scott Foldesi
· Karen Ganz
· Geoff Garza
· Wynne Greenwood
· Mandy Greer
· Lauren Grossman
· Victoria Haven
· Blake Haygood
· Patrick Holderfield
· Harold Hollingsworth
· Elizabeth Jameson
· Fay Jones
· Robert C. Jones
· Billy King
· Margot Quan Knight
· Charles Krafft
· Carolyn Krieg
· Amitara Kumar
· James Lavadour
· Deborah Faye Lawrence
· Lead Pencil
· Ingrid Lahti
· Isaac Layman
· Susie J. Lee
· Margie Livingston
· Hugo Ludena
· Spike Mafford
· Dante Marioni
· Anne Mathern
· Rachel Maxi
· Roy McMakin
· Robert Mirenzi
· William Morris
· Fred Muram
· Yuki Nakamura
· Ries Niemi
· Nicolas Nyland
· Oregon Department of Kick Ass
· Joseph Park
· Mary Ann Peters
· Charles Peterson
· Alexis M. Pike
· Tivon Rice
· Susan Robb
· Ginny Ruffner
· Harriet Sanderson
· Elizabeth Sandvig
· Alex Schweder
· Mike Simi
· Buster Simpson
· Preston Singletary
· Michael Spafford
· suttonberesculler
· Akio Takamori
· Alice Tippit
· Claude Zervas
· Jennifer Zwick
· Darren Waterston
· wabearchub
· Dan Webb
· Alice Wheeler

Art blogs via everywhere
· Aesthetic Grounds
· ANABA
· Art and Politics Now (Seattle)
· Art Fag City
· Artcatchr
· Artinfo
· Art Or Idiocy?
· Art Scatter
· Art Vent
· Avant Guardian
· Bay Area Art Quake!
· Best Of
· Best of 3
· Bloggy
· Brief Epigrams
· C-Monster
· Contrariwise: Literary Tattoos
· Culture Grrl
· Daily Campello
· Daily Serving
· Eco Art Blog
· Ekosystem
· Everything Everywhere All Of The Time
· Exhibitionist
· Expanded Field
· Exposures
· Roberta Fallon/Libby Rosof
· foto08
· Freese
· Greg.Org
· Hank Blog
· Heart As Arena
· I Heart Photograph
· (incli)NATION
· Jonathan Jones
· Jeff Weinstein: Out There
· Leap Into The Void
· Looking Around
· Lost And Found Photos
· Luminous Lint
· Lance Mannion
· Loreto Martin
· Joanne Mattera
· Modern Art Obsession
· Modern Art Notes
· NEWSgrist
· Oly's Musings
· Olympia Dumpster Divers
· OC Art Blog
· Over The Net
· Page 291
· Peripheral Vision
· D.K. Row - Oregon Live
· Rhizome
· Round About Seattle
· Stranger - Visual Art
· That's A Negative
· 1000 Words Photography
· Tomorrow Museum
· Two Coats of Paint
· Urban Honking
· VVORK
· Vroom Journal
· James Wagner
· We Make Money Not Art
· Edward_Winkleman
· Zoe Strauss

Seattle galleries
· Blvd
· Catherine Person
· Crawl Space
· Francine Seders
· G. Gibson
· Gallery I/M/A
· Greg Kucera
· Grey
· James Harris
· Howard House
· Lawrimore Project
· Martin-Zambito
· Linda Hodges
· OKOK
· Platform
· Punch
· Roq La Rue
· Soil
· Traver
· Wall of Sound
· Woodside/Braseth

Seattle art spaces
· Gallery 4Culture
· Hedreen Gallery
· Kirkland Arts Center
· Open Satellite
· McLeod Residence
· Photographic Center Northwest
· Suyama Space
· Western Bridge
· Wright Exhibition Space (No Web Site)
· Columbia City

Most recent posts
· Boomer Consumer: Questions raised by attorney general's letter to educate homeowners about foreclosure
· Seattle 911: Are U turns legal?
· Little Courtney, Big City: A titillating exhibit...

*Would you like to blog for us?

ADVERTISING
Advertising

Seattle Post-Intelligencer
101 Elliott Ave. W.
Seattle, WA 98119
(206) 448-8000

Home Delivery: (206) 464-2121 or (800) 542-0820
seattlepi.com serves about 1.7 million unique visitors
and 30 million page views each month.

Send comments to newmedia@seattlepi.com
Send investigative tips to iteam@seattlepi.com
©1996-2007 Seattle Post-Intelligencer
Terms of Use/Privacy Policy

Hearst Newspapers